In this reunited-lovers story, theater-geek-turned-theater-manager Callie Carpenter comes home to Lakeside, New Jersey, to take care of her recuperating parents. To cover the bills, she takes a substitute theater teacher gig at Lakeside’s high school, where her high school boyfriend Garrett Daniels is the history teacher and godlike football coach. Callie and Garrett quickly pick up where they left off, but with Callie’s return to San Diego looming, what’s the point of falling back in love?