Fan Casting

Once again framed by the tragic narration of Pariah, the cursed observer of collapsing worlds, Season 2 continues exploring fractured DC timelines, this time with stronger crossover elements and a serialized arc centered on a multiversal threat mysteriously tied to Selina Kyle as Batwoman. Episode 1 – What If… Demonia Joined the Thamarians? In an altered timeline, Stephenwolf destroys Tamaran, Demonia survives and becomes a hardened Thamarian, Blade Runner–inspired space noir. Episode 2 – What If… Primus Attacked Earth’s Mightiest Heroes? Set in 1988, a young Pren returns to Earth empowered by Omega energies granted by the tyrant Lord Damyn. Believing Earth’s champions to be future threats, he wages war against a retro Justice League lineup including Thomas Wayne as Batman, General Sam Lane, Ray Palmer, Atom Smasher, the Wizard Shazam, Abin Sur, and Wonder Woman. Manipulated by Damyn into seeking planetary conquest, Pren becomes a symbol of corrupted legacy until the League unites across generations to stop him in a climactic battle that nearly tears Earth apart. Episode 3 – What If… Jimmy Olsen Saved Christmas? A lighter, action-comedy tale set during the era of Superman III. When the Hall of Justice is seized by rogue operatives led by Metallo, Jimmy Olsen must defend it alone. Experimenting with confiscated Justice League tech including unstable Atlantean biomatter linked to Aquaman, Jimmy accidentally transforms into a water-powered super version of himself. Chaos ensues as he clumsily but heroically saves the day, proving heart matters more than powers. Episode 4 – What If… Superman Crashed into Warworld? After falling through a spatial anomaly, Superman lands on Warworld and is enslaved by Mongul. Teaming up with the warrior Artemis, Clark rises through gladiatorial ranks, forging solar-infused armor from scavenged alien technology. Rather than remaining a passive captive, he becomes a revolutionary symbol, ultimately leading a slave uprising that topples Mongul’s regime in spectacular cosmic combat. Episode 5 – What If… Selina Kyle Fought the Red Hood? Batwoman Selina confronts a corrupted Bruce Wayne, resurrected and twisted by prolonged exposure to the Lazarus Pit. As reality destabilizes due to Mother Box interference, Selina teams with Black Canary to save Bruce’s soul while preventing an interdimensional incursion. The emotional battle between love, guilt, and destiny ties directly into the season’s overarching multiversal imbalance. Episode 6 – What If… Kahhori Reshaped the World? Reimagined within DC lore, Kahhori is empowered by a fallen fragment of a Mother Box centuries before European colonization. Gifted with cosmic awareness and energy manipulation, she protects her people and dramatically alters world history, preventing empires from rising unchecked. Her existence creates a ripple effect across the timeline, forming one of the key nexus points Pariah observes with growing concern. Episode 7 – What If… The First Born Found the Blue Beetle? Banished and stripped of divine authority, First Born discovers the alien scarab of the Blue Beetle and bonds with its power. Facing the rival Black Beetle, he is forced to confront humility for the first time. The scarab tempers his brutality, reshaping him from a tyrant into a reluctant protector seeking balance rather than domination. Episode 8 – What If… The Justice League Assembled in a Medieval World? Inspired by Dark Knights of Steel, the League exists in a feudal fantasy realm where Bruce Wayne, Zatanna Zatara, and Wonder Woman are knights, sorcerers, and royal heirs. When Selina Kyle is mysteriously displaced into this era, she uncovers temporal distortions threatening the fabric of reality itself. Political intrigue, dragon-forged weapons, and ancient prophecy collide as Pariah realizes the timelines are beginning to bleed together. Episode 9 – What If… Fate Supreme Intervened? The season culminates with Doctor Fate, now Fate Supreme, returning as a morally ambiguous architect of reality who believes rewriting existence is the only way to prevent total multiversal collapse. Selina, Kahhori, First Born, and other altered heroes unite against him in a battle spanning shattered universes. Fate ultimately sacrifices himself, sealing the fractures at the cost of his own existence. As balance is restored, Pariah reflects that even intervention born of good intentions carries unbearable cost and though this crisis ends, infinite possibilities still threaten the fragile DC multiverse.