With the story of the Mathers case leaked to the press, Rudnick dead, and Slim in the wind, Damien has a lot on his plate as the new Captain of the precinct. Things get progressively worse, as Roger arrives to the city with his partner Timothy, Kimmy and Jordan decide to go to vacation, and a psychotic ventriloquist starts terrorizing the city. Roger reveals to Damien he was forced to kill the serial killer he was hunting for in the Pilot, The Peppermint Man, just as his (Peppermint Man's) brother arrives to Los Angeles with a plan of resurrecting him and, in order to achieve this, seeks help from his sister-in-law, Barbara. Far from all of this, David, Brina and Tyler finally start becoming a normal family again, but for how long?