Two years after Scarecrow was brutally beaten by Batman after the dark knight made an airborne antidote for Crane's fear toxin as Gotham was slowly getting back on track after the damage that the master of fear had done to the city along with those who have lost their lives and sanity, Jason Todd (Judd Nelson) who lost his friend Charles (Thomas F. Wilson) due to an altercation with a local thief, resulting in Reese getting shot. Bruce Wayne (Mel Gibson) has been doing his best to give his support for Jason despite the bad blood that developed after everything that Joker had done to Todd, Barbara and others, Todd resents Wayne for failing to save him.
Meanwhile, a new ventriloquist has been getting some light at the local comedy club in the form of Arnold Wesker (Robert Englund) who is doing well at his job. Diagnosed with DID as lately, the man has been developing a cruel
persona that took the guise to one of Wesker's many dummies. The mafia boss known as Scarface, stakes start to pile up as Wesker slowly loses himself over the new personality, Harleen Quinzel (Christine Elise) has been assigned to be the psychologist to The Joker, however The Clown Prince of Crime starts to manipulate the doctor into falling in love with him, thanks to Joker's mind games she has been slowly losing her mind until the fateful day of accidentally murdering her father. Harleen snapped and became something that was much worse.
